Whitefish's 2026 Tax Bills Follow the Owner's Calendar, Not the House

In late August the Whitefish City Council voted on its fiscal year 2027 budget and tied twice. The first motion, which would have picked up five additional mills, failed 3-3 after Mayor John Muhlfeld voted against it. The second motion, for 10 mills, also tied, and Muhlfeld broke that tie in favor, as the Daily Inter Lake reported. City Manager Dana Meeker then estimated what the decision meant for a home worth about $1 million. As a primary residence, its city taxes would rise about $53.06 a year. As a second home or short-term rental, the same house would see an increase of about $711.73.

Under the 2026 rules, the owner's use of a property can change the tax on a house even when its value and its street stay the same. Those bills are now arriving. Flathead County's Treasurer posted 2026 real estate tax amounts online in the last week of October, mailed copies followed, and the first half is due November 30. They are the first Whitefish bills calculated under Montana's split between homestead and non-homestead property. The tax figure attached to a house may say little about what the next owner will pay.

Homesteads and Second Homes

According to its 2026 tax information page, the Montana Department of Revenue lists a tiered schedule for qualifying primary residences and long-term rentals, and a flat 1.90% rate for second homes, short-term rentals and vacant residential lots.

The City's 10-Mill Decision

In Whitefish, the city's 2026 certified taxable value is about $121 million, and one mill equals roughly $121,346.

The reclassification itself moved the second-home bill even more than the mills did. Before the final vote, city staff ran three options for a property with a 2026 market value of $862,700, as the Flathead Beacon reported.

Budget option Primary residence, city portion Same property as second home or STR, city portion
Preliminary budget plus 5 mills +$0.51, about 0.07% +$448.14, about 61%
Preliminary budget plus 10 mills +$37.76, about 5.17% +$620.10, about 85%

Look at the five-mill row. For a primary residence, the city portion barely moved. For the same property as a second home, it rose 61%. The council did not cause most of that increase. In his September op-ed in the Whitefish Pilot, Mayor Muhlfeld traced the sequence. FY26 replaced a flat 1.35% residential rate with a graduated one. FY27 adds the homestead exemption and moves second homes and short-term rentals to a flat 1.9%. He called the second-home impact "a state-driven shift, not a local change."

Meeker made a related point in the Daily Inter Lake's budget coverage. She said the gap between $53.06 and $711.73 demonstrates the significant impact on second homes and the resulting relief for primary residences passed by the 2025 Legislature. These are estimates for the city portion only. County, school and state levies make up the rest of the bill.

A Smaller Levy Can Still Mean a Larger Bill

The county budget shows the same effect from another direction. Flathead County's fiscal year 2027 budget levies 101.12 mills, down from 102.62. County officials said many homeowners would see rates fall by $1.14 per $100,000 of assessed value, according to the Daily Inter Lake. The value of each mill also rose nearly 20%, to $667,426, and the levy is expected to raise about $64 million, roughly $10.4 million more than the prior year.

At the same meeting, Commissioner Pamela Holmquist noted that primary residences and second homes now carry different rates, so some bills will rise. "Many of them may see quite an increase," she said.

Whitefish also has one offset that most Montana towns lack. The resort tax, as approved by voters, sends 25% of collections to property tax relief. For FY27 that credit is $2,439,028, which the mayor puts at the equivalent of a 20.1-mill reduction citywide. That relief applies across the city's levy. It reduces the city line on every bill, but it does not close the rate gap between a homestead and a second home of the same value.

Why the Council Took the Mills This Year

The 10-mill vote also says something about where Whitefish expects the rules to go next. Carry-forward mills are unused levy authority that a local government can impose in a later year. Meeker told councilors there was legitimate reason to believe the 2027 Legislature could take that ability away. Councilor Andy Feury argued for the larger number, telling the Flathead Beacon that not picking up as many mills as possible

"would probably be the most irresponsible thing that we have ever done with the budget."

The city's carry-forward capacity dropped from 27.82 mills at the end of FY26 to 11.59 at the end of FY27. The mayor described the decision as being "about stability, not spending for spending's sake."

For a second-home owner, this changes how predictable future bills are. The cushion that once absorbed swings in the budget is now smaller. Any future mills Whitefish levies will fall on a base where second homes carry the heavier rate. The state rules behind that rate are also still in dispute.

Open Questions and Dates on the Calendar

Several pieces of the 2026 system are still unresolved:

  1. November 13. On October 21, Judge Andrew Bruener heard summary-judgment arguments in the January lawsuit challenging how SB 542 passed the Legislature. The case is in Gallatin County District Court. KTVH reported that he gave both sides until November 13 to submit proposed orders and would wait for them before taking action.
  2. A second suit. On October 13, Sen. Greg Hertz, Sen. Tom McGillvray and former Sen. Keith Regier filed a separate case. It argues that applying different rates to residential property within the same class violates equal protection, as the Flathead Beacon reported.
  3. November 30. The first half of 2026 Flathead County real estate taxes is due.
  4. The 2027 session. On the Montana Legislature's bill tracker, Dave Fern's draft LC0051, "Revise property taxes for second homes," was taken off hold October 21, 2026, and LC0053, "Revise residential property taxes," followed on October 22.
  5. May 31, 2027. The second half of the 2026 bill is due.

The Lawsuits

No ruling had been issued as of late October 2026. The first case is waiting on proposed orders due November 13, and the second was filed only in October.

If you are weighing a second home here, Slezak Group welcomes a private conversation.

Work With Us

Our success over the last 28 years is based on our commitment of quality over quantity and in taking the time to understand our clients needs and wants so we can provide the best possible options and experience. It takes a careful strategy to put together the perfect property and transaction that achieves demanding goals.

CONTACT US